Main

          Market Focus

          Research Paper

          Company Focus

          Economics & Other

          Earnings Summary

          Earnings Performance

          Warrant

          Calendar

          World Market

          Currency

          Download Research

          Video Squawk (Thai)

 
KIM ENG RESEARCH CENTER
February 12,2002


Foreign fund inflows – a warning from history

For the fourth time in as many years, strong inflows of foreign funds are driving up the Thai stock market. Between January 3 and February 8 this year, foreigners have been net buyers of Bt11.2bn of Thai stocks. During that time, the SET index has surged 16%, easily outperforming all the world’s major stock indices.

Table 1: Foreign net purchases and SET index

Period of strong gains

Chg + point (%)

Period of strong foreign net purchases

Net buy (Bt mn)

Jan13,98 – Feb3,98

+219.7 (+64.8%)

Jan13, 98 - Mar2, 98

+27,410

Apr16,99 - Jun22,99

+142 (+38.3%)

Apr16, 99 - Jun23, 99

+14,410

Jan4,01 - Jan25,01

+67.7 (+24.9%)

Jan4, 01 - Jan25, 01

+7,334

Jan3,02 - ???

+48.4 (+15.9%)

Jan3, 02 - ???

+11,175

The previous three rallies in which foreigners were heavy buyers sputtered out after 1-3 months, leaving many local investors who failed to exit in time with substantial losses. While there is no guarantee that the current rally will not meet the same fate, there are plenty of reasons to believe that the SET latest uptick, which began in mid-November, will prove more resilient than previous stock market rebounds in the past four years. These reasons include:

  1. The fall in interest rates, both at home and abroad, to historical lows
  2. Improvements in corporate profitability due to debt restructuring, low interest rates and less competition in some sectors.
  3. A strong revival in housing demand.
  4. Stable politics, with relatively little infighting among government coalition parties and no major controversies or scandals threatening to topple the government.
  5. Cheap valuations and high dividend yields for many Thai stocks
  6. A series of measures by the Thaksin government to support the stock and property markets
  7. Diversification of assets away from some major stock markets following the bursting of the tech bubble, the Enron scandal and persistent weakness of the Japanese economy,

Despite our optimism that foreign buying will help drive the SET index past the 400 mark before year-end, investors need to keep a close eye on foreign net buy/sell figures to ensure they are not left holding overpriced stocks when the market turns. The other pointer for a trend reversal is the performance of other Asian markets, particularly the other two TIP countries – the Philippines and Indonesia.

Table 2: Performance of Asian stock markets during bull runs in last 4 years

Market

Jan13,98 - Feb3,98

Apr16,99 - Jun22,99

Jan4,01 - Jan25,01

Jan3,02 - ???

Thailand

+219.7 (+64.8%)

+142 (+38.3%)

+67.7 (+24.9%)

+48.4 (+15.9%)

Indonesia

+186.6 (+53.3%)

+263.2 (+58.5%)

+54 (+13.1%)

+53.5 (+14%)

Philippines

+553 (+36.1%)

+302 (+13.9%)

+242.2 (+16.7%)

+174 (+14.9%)

Singapore

+344.4 (+32.1%)

+417.1 (+24.4%)

+52.7 (+2.8%)

+110.7 (+6.8%)

Malaysia

+223.7 (+46.8%)

+211.5 (+36.3%)

+57.6 (+8.8%)

+28.1 (+4.1%)

Korea

+94 (+20.6%)

+154 (+21.3%)

+106.1 (+20.3%)

+14.7 (+2%)

As our table above shows, Asian stocks markets tend to rise – and fall – together. The table also shows a striking correlation between the SET and the Indonesian and Philippine markets. Malaysia performed broadly in line with Thailand during 1998-9 but has substantially underperformed against the SET in the current rally and the one just over a year ago.

Although the current rally is liquidity-driven, the SET is back on foreign fund managers’ radar screens due to its recovery potential following five years of economic and corporate turbulence. The major threat to the rally is if economic indicators or corporate earnings fail to match investors’ growing expectations. This is a relatively low risk at this stage but earnings disappointments, particularly in the banking and finance sectors, have thwarted some of the SET’s previous attempts to mount a sustained recovery.

 

Net foreign purchases and SET’s performance

To remind investors that foreign fund flows can vanish almost as quickly as they appear, we have looked back on the three previous foreigner-led rallies - and what caused them to run out of steam

  • Rally 1 (Jan 13–Feb 3 1998)

SET index surged 219.7 points or 64.8% to peak at 558.9 on foreign net purchases of Bt27.4bn. Reasons: baht strengthens to Bt47.2/US$ after hitting record low of Bt56.5/US$; and interbank rate drops to 21% after peaking at 25-30%. Why it fizzled: economy contracted following the closure of 56 financial institutions and the rising number of NPLs among banks; regional economic crisis spreads to South Korea and Indonesia. Result: index hits its lowest point of 207 in September 1998.

  • Rally 2 (Apr 16, 1999–June 22, 1999)

SET index rises 142 points or 38.3% to peak at 545.9, with foreigner buying a net total of Bt14.4bn of Thai stocks. The reasons: falling interest rates, with interbank rate down to 1.75-2% and MLR declining to 9.75% from 15.5%; baht rises to Bt37.5/US$; government approves new bankruptcy court and establishes new central bank agency to resolve NPL problems. Why it fizzled: low interest rates were not enough to stimulate Thai economy by themselves; baht begins to weaken after US increases interest rates. Result: Thai stock market falls to 367 in Oct 1999.

  • Rally 3 (Jan 4– Jan 25, 2001)

SET index climbs 67.7 points or 24.9% to peak at 339.7 on foreign net buying of Bt7.3bn. The reasons: confidence in Thailand’s political stability rekindled following landslide election victory of Thaksin Shinawatra’s Thai Rak Thai Party; bank and finance shares rally on hopes that Thaksin’s plan for a new bank bailout agency – the Thai Asset Management Corp (TAMC) will resolve bad debts problem. Why it fizzled: Disillusionment with TAMC and threat to Thaksin’s political career on asset concealment charges. Result: Thaksin acquittal in August briefly sends market back to 2001 peak before SET index plunges to year-low of 265 last November in wake of September 11 terrorist attacks. 

 

Analyst : Surachai Pramualcharoenkit
Surachai.p@kimeng.co.th

 

 


If you have any questions or suggestions please feel free to email our  Research Webmaster

Copyright © March 2000, Kim Eng Securities (Thailand) PLC. All rights reserved.

Disclaimer

Click Here!